Nothing read from this blog should be considered sound legal advice. Please speak with a lawyer.
Probable cause is a crucial legal standard that law enforcement officers must meet to justify an arrest, search, or seizure. During a field sobriety test, establishing probable cause is essential for determining whether a driver is impaired and should be arrested for driving under the influence (DUI). Here’s a detailed look at how probable cause is determined during a field sobriety test.
What is Probable Cause?
Legal Definition: Probable cause refers to the reasonable belief, based on factual evidence, that a person has committed a crime. In the context of a DUI, it means the officer has sufficient evidence to believe the driver is impaired by alcohol or drugs.
Importance in DUI Cases: Without probable cause, any arrest or evidence gathered can be challenged in court, potentially leading to dismissal of charges.
Steps to Establish Probable Cause
- Initial ObservationsBehavioral Indicators: Officers look for signs of impairment such as erratic driving, swerving, or failing to obey traffic signals. Once the driver is stopped, further indicators include slurred speech, bloodshot eyes, and the smell of alcohol.
- Field Sobriety Tests (FSTs)Standardized Tests: Officers use Standardized Field Sobriety Tests (SFSTs) to assess a driver’s physical and cognitive abilities. These tests include:
- Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN): Observing eye movement as the driver follows a moving object.
- Walk-and-Turn (WAT): Evaluating balance and ability to follow instructions by walking heel-to-toe along a straight line.
- One-Leg Stand (OLS): Assessing balance and concentration by having the driver stand on one leg while counting aloud.
- Documentation and Evidence Collection
- Detailed Notes: Officers take meticulous notes on the driver’s performance during the tests, noting any signs of impairment such as inability to maintain balance, starting too soon, or incorrect steps.
- Video Evidence: Many police vehicles are equipped with dashboard cameras that record the entire interaction, providing visual evidence of the driver’s behavior and performance on the tests.
- Breathalyzer and Chemical Tests
- Breath Tests: If the field sobriety tests indicate impairment, officers may administer a breathalyzer test to measure the driver’s blood alcohol content (BAC). A BAC above the legal limit provides strong evidence of impairment.
- Blood or Urine Tests: In some cases, officers may request a blood or urine test to detect the presence of drugs. These tests are typically conducted at a medical facility.
Legal and Procedural Considerations
Adherence to Protocol: To ensure the validity of the arrest and any subsequent legal proceedings, officers must strictly adhere to established protocols. This includes correctly administering the SFSTs and properly documenting all observations and test results.
Driver’s Rights: Throughout the process, officers must respect the driver’s legal rights. This includes informing them of the consequences of refusing to take the tests and ensuring they understand their right to legal representation.
Conclusion
Probable cause is a fundamental aspect of DUI enforcement, ensuring that any arrest is based on solid, factual evidence of impairment. Through careful observation, standardized testing, and thorough documentation, police officers can establish probable cause during a field sobriety test.
Understanding the steps involved in determining probable cause helps drivers appreciate the rigorous standards law enforcement must meet to ensure fairness and legal compliance. By maintaining these standards, officers uphold the integrity of the legal process and contribute to safer roads for everyone.
Field sobriety tests, combined with the requirement for probable cause, play a vital role in identifying and prosecuting impaired drivers, thereby enhancing public safety.
